Floyd post TFC Vs Waters

Here is a very simple way of working out who is a better artist Floyd after TFC (Gilmour) or Waters.

I give you all two options..

Option 1, you have the two post TCF Floyd albums removed from your house never to be heard again as long as you live.

Option 2 - you have the three post TCF Waters albums removed from your house never to be heard again as long as you live.

A very simple question - no you will never hear them again through your pc / a friend / radio / any other means you can think of.

Do you take OPTION 1 OR OPTION 2.

Myself - OPTION 1

Warren - bored in Melbourne Australia

BTW - for those that wish to give us irrelevant commentries/analysis/flames etc do try and put at the top or bottom of your post OPTION 1 OR 2 so we can have a fair idea on your views. For those who sit on the fence and think they should all be one big happy family just be honest it ain't happening and is completely unrealistic as opposed to my realistic option

1. Take a dump in your hand 2. Closer your eyes and fling it at your CD collection 3. Whichever album the largest chunk lands on is the WINNER !!!!

Can I just write in 'Gary Cooper' ?

Strange...as all of 'em share a CD shelf not 4 feet from me, that seems pretty realistic to me.

So you can't give us an option - it is to difficult for you to write OPTION 1 OR 2. Are you saying all 5 cds are crap. Give us your irrelevant commentary but what about an option - is it to much to ask. Option spelt O P T I O N - 1 IS ABOVE THE Q TWO IS ABOVE THE W.

Bleech I know you can do it.

I definitely choose Option 1 as well .... a life without 'Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking' would be incredibly sad ... its still my favorite album of all time .... No 'Amused To Death'??? I'd go nuts ....

'Radio KAOS', well although I love that, I'd probably choose the Floyd albums over it if a gun was to my head ... but no one could ever take 'Pros and Cons' and 'Amused' away from me.

I've pretty much already doen this, if that counts for anything.

I ASKED you if I could write in Gary Cooper, G A R Y C O O P E R

And what was the response.]

Option 1.

Bill

Option 2

waters stuff is too hard too swallow at times, as where floyds is much more easier on the ears

Christ. It's you again. Oh well. I suspect that your plan will merely provide a vague pointer to which people prefer, not that it needs another investigation. For my part, I don't actually have any of Waters' solo works to be rid of, which has saved me a great deal of time, money, effort and psychotherapy.

Sad Ken - five years on amp-f, and still none the wiser

Again a beautiful answer, - guys we are getting better.